Published
- 6 min read
Grading trades: Evaluating six deals, including...
Grading trades: Evaluating six deals, including DeForest Buckner’s return to the 49ers
Deal Overview: DeForest Buckner to Indianapolis Colts (2020)
The San Francisco 49ers traded defensive tackle DeForest Buckner to the Indianapolis Colts for the No. 13 overall pick in the 2020 NFL Draft. Buckner subsequently signed a five-year, $100 million deal with the Colts.
Key Stats & Facts
- Buckner (Colts, 2020-2023):
- 2020: 9.5 sacks, 3 forced fumbles (First-Team All-Pro)
- Career with Colts: 32.5 sacks, 36 TFL, 3 Pro Bowl selections.
- Indianapolis defense consistently ranked top-10 in pressures and run defense with Buckner as anchor.
- 49ers (Draft Capital):
- Selected DT Javon Kinlaw with the No. 13 pick.
- Kinlaw (49ers, 2020-2023): 8.5 career sacks in 47 games, battled injuries and inconsistent play.
Player Spotlight & Standings Impact
Buckner immediately became an elite interior force for the Colts, anchoring their defensive line and earning All-Pro honors in his first season. He consistently pressured quarterbacks and excelled against the run, becoming a foundational piece. The trade significantly elevated the Colts’ defense, contributing to playoff appearances in 2020 and 2021. For the 49ers, while Kinlaw did not replicate Buckner’s impact, the cap savings allowed other key acquisitions, and the team maintained a strong defensive unit en route to multiple NFC Championship games and Super Bowl LVIII.
Deal Overview: Stefon Diggs to Buffalo Bills (2020)
The Minnesota Vikings traded wide receiver Stefon Diggs and a 2020 seventh-round pick to the Buffalo Bills for a 2020 first-round pick (No. 22 overall), a 2020 fifth-round pick, a 2020 sixth-round pick, and a 2021 fourth-round pick.
Key Stats & Facts
- Diggs (Bills, 2020-2023):
- 2020: 127 receptions, 1,535 yards, 8 TDs (NFL receiving yards leader, First-Team All-Pro)
- Career with Bills: 445 receptions, 5,372 yards, 37 TDs in 66 games.
- Four consecutive 1,000-yard seasons.
- Vikings (Draft Capital):
- Used No. 22 pick on WR Justin Jefferson, who became an All-Pro talent.
Player Spotlight & Standings Impact
Diggs instantly transformed the Bills’ offense, becoming Josh Allen’s top target and elevating the entire passing game. His arrival coincided with Allen’s MVP-caliber rise. The Bills became an AFC powerhouse, winning four consecutive AFC East titles (2020-2023) and consistently reaching the playoffs. The Vikings successfully drafted a superstar in Jefferson, mitigating the loss, but the Bills’ immediate and sustained success highlights the trade’s massive impact.
Deal Overview: Matthew Stafford to Los Angeles Rams (2021)
The Detroit Lions traded quarterback Matthew Stafford to the Los Angeles Rams for QB Jared Goff, a 2021 third-round pick, a 2022 first-round pick, and a 2023 first-round pick.
Key Stats & Facts
- Stafford (Rams, 2021-2023):
- 2021 Regular Season: 4,886 passing yards, 41 TDs, 17 INTs.
- 2021 Postseason: 1,188 passing yards, 9 TDs, 3 INTs across 4 games.
- Super Bowl LVI: 283 yards, 3 TDs, 2 INTs (victory over Bengals).
- Rams’ Draft Capital Expenditure: Two first-round picks, one third-round pick.
Player Spotlight & Standings Impact
Stafford provided the elite quarterback play the Rams sought, culminating in a Super Bowl LVI victory in his first season. His clutch performances in the playoffs solidified the trade as a resounding success for Los Angeles. The Rams immediately contended for a championship, demonstrating the value of a proven veteran quarterback. For the Lions, the trade initiated a successful rebuild under Goff, leading to an NFC Championship appearance in 2023.
Deal Overview: Tyreek Hill to Miami Dolphins (2022)
The Kansas City Chiefs traded wide receiver Tyreek Hill to the Miami Dolphins for a 2022 first-round pick (No. 29 overall), a 2022 second-round pick, a 2022 fourth-round pick, and 2023 fourth-round and sixth-round picks. Hill signed a four-year, $120 million extension with Miami.
Key Stats & Facts
- Hill (Dolphins, 2022-2023):
- 2022: 119 receptions, 1,710 yards, 7 TDs.
- 2023: 119 receptions, 1,799 yards, 13 TDs (led NFL in receiving yards per game).
- Broke Dolphins’ single-season receiving yardage record twice.
- Dolphins’ Offensive Rankings (2022-2023): Top-10 in total offense and passing offense.
Player Spotlight & Standings Impact
Hill transformed the Dolphins’ offense, providing unparalleled speed and big-play ability. He immediately elevated Tua Tagovailoa’s performance and helped propel Miami to consecutive playoff berths (2022, 2023) after a long drought. His consistent elite production proved the high draft capital and contract were justified. The Chiefs utilized the draft capital to maintain a championship roster, winning two more Super Bowls without Hill, but Miami’s offensive explosion is directly attributable to his arrival.
Deal Overview: Jamal Adams to Seattle Seahawks (2020)
The New York Jets traded safety Jamal Adams and a 2022 fourth-round pick to the Seattle Seahawks for two first-round picks (2021, 2022), a 2021 third-round pick, and safety Bradley McDougald. Adams signed a four-year, $70 million extension in 2021.
Key Stats & Facts
- Adams (Seahawks, 2020-2023):
- 2020: 9.5 sacks (single-season record for a defensive back), First-Team All-Pro.
- 2021-2023: Played just 22 games due to significant injuries (quad, shoulder).
- Zero sacks, 2 INTs across his last two full seasons.
- Jets (Draft Capital):
- Used 2021 first-round pick on OL Alijah Vera-Tucker.
- Used 2022 first-round pick on WR Garrett Wilson (Offensive Rookie of the Year).
Player Spotlight & Standings Impact
Adams’s first season in Seattle was phenomenal, highlighted by a record-breaking sack total. However, the subsequent years were plagued by major injuries, severely limiting his impact and availability. The significant draft capital surrendered, combined with Adams’s injury history and high contract, made this trade a net loss for the Seahawks, who struggled to maintain consistent playoff contention after 2020. The Jets, conversely, used the acquired picks to draft key offensive cornerstones, significantly aiding their rebuild.
Deal Overview: Khalil Mack to Chicago Bears (2018)
The Oakland Raiders traded outside linebacker Khalil Mack, a 2020 second-round pick, and a 2020 fifth-round pick to the Chicago Bears for two first-round picks (2019, 2020), a 2020 third-round pick, and a 2019 sixth-round pick. Mack signed a six-year, $141 million deal.
Key Stats & Facts
- Mack (Bears, 2018-2021):
- 2018: 12.5 sacks, 6 forced fumbles, 1 INT (returned for TD). Named Defensive Player of the Year.
- Career with Bears: 36 sacks, 14 forced fumbles in 53 games.
- Injuries limited him in 2020 and 2021, playing 11 and 7 games respectively.
- Bears’ Defensive Rankings (2018): Led NFL in takeaways (36), ranked 3rd in points allowed.
Player Spotlight & Standings Impact
Mack’s immediate impact on the Bears was historic, anchoring a dominant defense that led them to the NFC North title in 2018. His Defensive Player of the Year season proved he was worth the exorbitant cost. However, after 2018, his production declined due to injuries, and the Bears failed to sustain their elite defensive play or overall team success. While the initial return was massive, the long-term cost and injury issues made the trade a mixed bag for Chicago. The Raiders leveraged the picks to bolster their roster, though without the immediate star power Mack provided.